The case of the taxpayer who was paid too late

HomeInsights

The case of the taxpayer who was paid too late.


What a difference timing makes. A recent case before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) is a reminder about the tax impact of the timing of employment income. 


When the job ended, the taxpayer moved to Australia and became a resident. Once in Australia, the former employer honoured the performance bonus and paid it as a series of instalments.


The dispute between the ATO and the taxpayer started when the Commissioner issued amended assessments taxing the bonus payments received.


The dispute focused on when the bonus was derived. Had the bonus been derived while the taxpayer was still a non-resident then it would not have been taxed in Australia.


This is because non-residents are normally only taxed in Australia on Australian sourced income. Employment income is typically sourced in the place where the work is performed (although there can be exceptions to this).


Australian tax case law says that employment income is normally derived on receipt. In the taxpayer’s case, this was when he received the payments from his former employer, not when he became entitled to the bonus. Because the taxpayer received the bonus when he was a tax resident of Australia, the bonus was subject to tax.


The difference for the taxpayer was quite dramatic. Had he been paid the bonus when it was due, he would have paid no tax as Kuwait does not impose income tax.


Let's work together.

Please call us if you are concerned about tax residency or managing overseas income. We want our people to be the best they can be.


CONTACT US  CONTACT US 



SMSF Loans and Property Investment

It would seem SMSF loans have become an increasingly popular way to access the capital required to get a foothold on the property ladder.


The New Lifetime Director IDs

Directors will be required to register for a unique identification number that they will keep for life, much like a tax file number under a rewrite of Australia’s business registers.


Your SMSF: when expenses and investments are not at arm’s-length

We often get questions from clients about what they can and cannot do in their SMSF. Often the questions relate to related party transactions – that is, interactions between the SMSF, its assets, and its members (or relatives of members).  We’ve set out some of the common questions and answers.


The Balancing Act: 2021/22 Federal Budget

The 2021-22 Federal Budget is a balancing act between a better than anticipated deficit ($106 bn), an impending election, and the need to invest in the long term.


Tax and Cash Flow Planning

When an accountant talks about Tax Planning what do they actually mean? As part of our tax advisory service we always offer strategic tax advisory, but it's important to note there are a lot of things that accountants cannot implement after June 30.


Tax Relief for Small Brewers & Distillers to Support Jobs

Small brewers and distillers will benefit from $255 million in tax relief to support more jobs and investment as part of the 2021-22 Budget.


Know Your Numbers


March Market Wrap

The rollout of Covid vaccines remained the key focus worldwide. More than 30% of adults in the US have now received at least one jab, for example, and new infections are down by around 80% since the peak in January.


Minimise Your Business Tax: The Guide

Here’s a guide to the strategies you can use to minimise your business tax.


Minimise Your Personal Tax: The Guide

Now's the time to review what strategies you can use to minimise your tax before 30 June 2022.


The July 2021 Superannuation Changes

Changes from 1 July 2021 will impact on how much money you can contribute to superannuation and how much you can have in your retirement phase superannuation account.


Tax & Rental Properties


National Licence Recognition For Tradies

Builders, electricians, plumbers, architects, real estate agents, security guards and other workers who hold an occupational licence in their home state or territory will soon be automatically deemed to have the necessary licence in other states.


How Much Super Is Enough?

What’s the magic amount you need in your super account to retire comfortably?


Rhino 4x4

Rhino 4x4 directors had been previously working with another accountant using MYOB, but they just didn’t have the commercial knowledge that they needed nor the visibility into the numbers. Enter Shannon Smit and the team from Smart Business Solutions to take Rhino 4x4 to the next level.


What is an Estate Briefing Paper?

Having an Estate Briefing Paper prepared by strategic tax advisors means that we can guide the structure of your Estate Plan to ensure your assets will be managed and transferred to your beneficiaries in the most financially efficient and tax effective way.


Important Tax Update for Medical Professionals - ATO Income Changes


Thinking Different Post-COVID: Lunch & Learn LIVE Workshop


SMART Life - Issue 4 - Autumn 2021


The Conversation Everyone Needs To Have


Protection For Every Stage Of Life


February Market Wrap

Australian inflation recorded at 0.9% in the 2020 calendar year, nearly double what the Reserve Bank of Australia forecasted in November’s Statement on Monetary Policy.


Protection At Every Stage Of Life


Divorce & Relationship Breakdowns

The tax impacts you need to know with divorce and relationship breakdowns including some of the areas that may impact you and where you may need assistance for your SMSF, Trusts and Estate Planning.


Divorce & Relationship Breakdowns


XERO Me Payroll App


JobMaker Hiring Credits - Eligibility & Management


WEBINAR: JobMaker Credits - Eligibility & Management

In the 2020-21 Federal Budget, the Government announced the introduction of a new JobMaker Hiring Credit to stimulate job creation. This webinar helps you understand your eligibility for JobMaker credits so you can take appropriate steps to avoid missing out on payments from the ATO.


2021 Investment Risks & Opportunities

With the borders between the State and Territories all but open and 2021 in sight, there is a hunger for a return to normal. With Australia's desire to ‘get on with things,' sentiment reached its highest level since November 2013 and Christmas spending is expected to be consistent with previous years.


Healthy and Wealthy New Year

As the holiday season winds up, it’s easy to be distracted from your financial goals. But this is actually the perfect time to put a few simple plans in place for a positive start to the new year.


December Market Wrap

The US election had earlier dominated attention. Donald Trump’s reluctance to concede diverted attention from possible policy changes under the new Biden administration, but this will likely become an increasing focus for investors in the months ahead.


How much insurance cover do I need?


Investing in Commercial Property


SMART Life - Issue 3 - Summer


SMSF - Is It The Right Investment Strategy For You?


WEBINAR: SMSF - Is it the right strategy for you?


Tax deductions for investing in your business

Stimulating investment is high on the Government’s agenda. To encourage spending, the 2021-22 Budget introduced a measure that allows businesses to immediately deduct the cost of new depreciable assets and the cost of improvements to existing assets in the first year of use.


JobMaker Hiring Credits: What we know so far

We’ve had quite a few questions about the JobMaker hiring credit announced in the 2020-21 Federal Budget. The legislation enabling the JobMaker scheme has not passed Parliament as yet and until this occurs, the JobMaker rules are not certain and may change.


Property Subdivision: The tax need-to-knows to ensure a profitable project

You've got a big block with big plans to subdivide in order to make big bucks. But do you know the ins-and-outs of property development from a TAX perspective? Before you jump in and commit to anything, it is important to understand the tax liabilities that might arise from your projects that will affect your overall profitability.


How would your life be affected if you had no income

The idea of insuring against loss of income is one that has clear value. The idea of insuring against loss of income is one that has clear value. Yet many neglect to insure their most valuable asset. Income protection could be the answer – so how does it work?


WEBINAR: Property Subdivision ~ The ATO Need-To-Knows


What should I consider with waiting periods?


Prossor Town Planning

Prossor Town Planning is dedicated to help people obtain planning permits across industrial, commercial residential and green wedge developments. Jackie Prossor tells us why engaging Shannon Smit as her business accountant, in addition to being her financial planner and business coach, makes perfect sense.


How to invest in Direct Equities


Guyrobb Electrics

Director and owner Jon Robbins first engaged SMART Business Solutions as their accountant in 2014. Jon was looking for a proactive accountant and business advisor who would listen to him, take the time to understand his business, and work together collaboratively.


HOW TO Give Your Employees a Cash Boost At No Cost To You


What is a buy back option?


Budget 2020-2021 Update

The 2020-21 Federal Budget is a road to recovery paved with cash. Some of the measures are aimed at addressing the harsh lessons COVID-19 has taught us and seek to centralise production back in Australia to ensure our industries can be self-reliant.

 

IFA Marketing Consultant 2020

IFA Marketing Consultant 2020

IFA Marketing Initiative 2021

IFA Marketing Initiative 2021


JobKeeper Extension: How to notify the ATO via the portal

Related News

5 May

ATO Targets Property Development Structures - What You Need to Know

The ATO has released Draft Practical Compliance Guideline PCG 2026/D2, and it’s very clear where they’re focusing next, property development structures, particularly where land ownership and development activities are split.


READ MORE READ MORE
20 Apr

The Power of Tax Planning for Small Business

Tax planning is more than just a financial necessity—it's a strategic advantage for businesses of all sizes. By proactively managing your tax strategy, you can significantly reduce your liabilities, enhance cash flow, and ensure full compliance with ever-evolving tax regulations.


READ MORE READ MORE
20 Apr

Your 2026 EOFY Game Plan

Smart and strategic tax planning for business.


READ MORE READ MORE