+61 (3) 5911 7000 +61 (3) 5911 7000

Up to 10 years in prison for deliberate ‘wage theft’

Home • Insights

Up to 10 years in prison for deliberate ‘wage theft’.


Legislation currently being debated in Parliament will introduce a new criminal offence for intentional “wage theft”. If enacted, in addition to the criminal offence, a fine will apply.  


The fine is three times the underpayment and:

  • For individuals - 5,000 penalty units (currently $1,565,000).
  • For businesses - 25,000 penalty units (currently $7,825,000).


The reforms are not intended to capture unintentional mistakes and a compliance ‘safe harbour’ will be introduced by the Fair Work Ombudsman for small businesses.

In addition to addressing wage theft, the Bill also seeks to:

  • Replace the definition of a ‘casual employee’ and create a pathway to permanent work.
  • Change the test for ‘sham contracting’ from a test of ‘recklessness’ to ‘reasonableness.’
  • Bolster the powers of the Fair Work Commission including the ability to set minimum standards for ‘employee-like’ workers including those in the gig economy.
  • Introduce a new offence of “industrial manslaughter” in the Work Health and Safety Act 2011.


What happens when a trust appoints income to a private company beneficiary but does not actually make the payment?

The tax treatment of this unpaid amount was at the centre of a recent case before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) that saw a taxpayer successfully challenge the ATO’s long held position (Bendel and Commissioner of Taxation [2023] AATA 3074). For many years, the ATO’s position has been that if a trust appoints income to a private company beneficiary but does not actually make the payment, this unpaid amount can be treated as a loan. Under Division 7A of the tax rules, these loans can be taxed as unfranked dividends unless they are managed using a complying loan agreement with annual principal and interest repayments.

This AAT decision challenges an important ATO position, with the tax outcomes being potentially significant for trust clients that currently owe (or may have owed in the past) unpaid trust entitlements to related private companies.

But this is not the end of this story. On 26 October 2023, the Tax Commissioner lodged a notice of appeal to the Federal Court. There is no guarantee that the Federal Court will reach the same conclusion as the AAT. We will need to wait and see.

Let's work together.

We want our people to be the best they can be.


CONTACT US  CONTACT US 



How important is quality in your business? Find out how to measure quality…

Quality Matters – Independent review with outstanding results for SMART Business Solutions


How do you get the Best Value from Your Accountant?

Paying an accountant to handle all of your financial reporting can be expensive, but if you have several different sources and deductions or if you own a small business, it can be worth it.


Using debtor finance to relieve cash flow pressure

Is your business thriving, but you struggle to maintain positive cash flow?


It’s all about the structure, should I be trading in a company and not a trust?

Don’t let it crumble from underneath you


BAS are you ready?

It’s nearly BAS time again - tips to make BAS processing easier

BAS time seems to come around quicker and quicker! Here are some tips to try and make it a little easier!


Year end checklists & questionnaires to get you organised

With June 30 quickly approaching we are pleased to provide our year end checklists and questionnaires to help you get organised.

Aus-Accounting-Awards-2015

Aus-Accounting-Awards-2015

Related News

12 Nov

We Want to Help With Your Loan, But There Are Some Things We Cannot Sign Off On

Your lender has asked for an accountant’s letter, but there are some things we cannot certify. Here is why these requests can create problems, what your accountant can confirm and how we can still help keep your application moving.


READ MORE READ MORE
12 Nov

Division 7A: You’re Not Saving Tax, You’re Borrowing It

Taking money from your company as a Division 7A loan can defer tax today, but the repayments and interest can create pressure later. Here is why it pays to understand the longer-term impact before you draw the funds.


READ MORE READ MORE
12 Nov

Bought a Car? The ATO Will Know

Buying or selling a vehicle can tell the ATO more than you might realise. Here is how vehicle data matching works, what information may be collected and why your ownership, business use and tax records need to tell the same story.


READ MORE READ MORE