Chobani plain yoghurt is GST-free but Chobani’s ‘flip’ range is taxable?
Back in 2000 when the Goods & Services Tax (GST) was first introduced, basic food was excluded to secure the support of the Democrats
for the new tax regime. Twenty three years later, the result of this exclusion is an unwieldy dividing line between GST-free and taxable
foods that is consistently tested and altered. It is this dividing line that US yoghurt giant Chobani Pty Ltd recently tested in a case
before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal
(AAT).
At the centre of the case was Chobani’s Flip Strawberry Shortcake flavoured yoghurt and whether the product, composed of a tub of strawberry
flavoured yoghurt with a separate tub of baked cookie and white chocolate pieces, is subject to GST. If the two components were sold in
isolation, the baked cookie pieces would be taxable and the yoghurt GST-free.
Chobani had originally treated the flip yoghurt range as GST-free, relying on a 2001 GST ruling that allowed “a supply that appears to have
more than one part but is essentially a supply of one thing” to be a composite supply. A product that is a composite supply could be treated
as GST-free if the other components did not exceed the lesser of $3 or 20% of the overall product. In Chobani’s case, this meant that they
could treat the flip yoghurt as GST-free.
Then in 2021, the ATO advised Chobani that its position had changed and it intended to treat the flip yoghurt as a combination food and
therefore taxable.
Under the GST system, ‘combination foods’ where at least one of the food components is taxable, are subject to GST. Lunch packs of tuna and
crackers, for example, are a combination food and therefore GST applies to the whole product because it is intended that the tuna and
crackers are eaten together.
But, where the food is a ‘mixed supply’, where each item is separate from the other and not intended to be consumed together, the GST will
apply (or not) to each individual product. An example would be a hamper.
In the Chobani case, the AAT found in favour of the Commissioner’s interpretation that the flip product was a combination food and therefore
subject to GST on the whole product.
The outcome of the Chobani test case has a number of implications. The first is that the ATO has issued a new draft GST ruling on
combination foods (GST 2023/D1)
replacing the previous guidance.
The second implication is that at least one classification on the ATO’s GST
status of major product lines
list will change. Weirdly, dip (with biscuits, wrapped individually and packaged together), was listed as a mixed supply, not a combination
food.
In a previous case, Birds Eye (Simplot Australia) was also unsuccessful in its appeal to the Federal
Court
that their frozen vegetable products that combined omelette, rice or grains were GST-free. The Court determined that the foods were either
prepared meals or a combination of foods and therefore taxable.
For food manufacturers, importers and distributors, it is important to keep up to date with the changing GST landscape and ensure that you
are utilising the correct classifications - it’s a moving feast!
Whilst our website offers an overview of the industry advice and licensing requirements, we encourage you to make an appointment with our industry advisors to have an in depth discussion.
On 31 March, the Fringe Benefits Tax (FBT) year ends. With the ever increasing budget deficits, the ATO will be reviewing whether all employers who should be paying FBT are, and that they are paying the right amount. Who needs to lodge a FBT return? Find out here.
If you’re a director of a small business, Payday Super isn’t just an HR or payroll issue. It’s a governance issue that could directly affect your personal legal exposure.
